Was He a Coward? (1915)

November 17, 2026

—

Barney McPhee | Margaret Vale

Marguerite Risser (1915) | www.vintoz.com

—

“Was He a Coward?”

An I. S. Plaut feature, full of thrills and propounding a hard question.

Reviewed by W. Stephen Bush.

This coming release of the I. S. Plaut Company, Was He a Coward? is a good, strong picture. It has had considerable publicity, owing to the daredevil feats of the hero, one Barney McPhee, and to the fact that the young woman who takes the leading part is said to be a niece of President Wilson. Both Mr. McPhee and Miss Vale, the heroine, show no lack of motion picture experience, though the fact is not unduly obvious.

In the main, the story follows conventional lines. The spendthrift son of a wealthy father exhausts the patience of his parent and is told to leave the paternal roof. He leaves, and, as the title puts it, “Fate deals harshly with him.” He is arrested on a charge of picking an old man’s pocket and, though innocent, he is found guilty and sentenced to prison. He breaks out of prison with another convict, which gives the photographer a chance to show a thrilling climbing feat on the wall of the prison. For a time he succeeds in concealing his identity, but after he has saved a banker’s daughter and is on the high road to prosperity he is recognized as an ex-convict by the detective who arrested him for the first time. He is vindicated on the original charge, but is punished for breaking out of jail. He performs prodigies of daring all through the film; pursued by the detective he jumps from a cliff into the roaring river below, a height of more than a hundred feet.

Nobody blames the detective for not jumping after him. He again jumps from the Harlem Bridge, and there is a most thrilling rescue of a woman who, we are assured, was going down for the third time when Barney made his wonderful plunge. It would take up too much space to record all of Barney’s daring deeds. We are glad to see that in the end he comes out of it all with a whole skin and a cheerful disposition. The banker’s daughter admires him so much that she insists on becoming his wife, but Barney, though madly in love with the girl, refuses to marry her, realizing that the shadow that has fallen upon his own life might throw itself across the life of his future life partner.

—

Scene from Was He a Coward? (I. S. Plaut)

—

Collection: Moving Picture World, February 1915