The Mountain Rat (1914)

December 02, 2025

—

Henry B. Walthall | Irene Hunt | James Kirkwood (Director)

Rest of cast:

Dorothy Gish | Donald Crisp | Josephine Crowell | Mary Rider (Story) | Frank E. Woods (Scenario)

—

“The Mountain Rat”

A special four-part feature pictureplay produced by the Reliance (R. & M.) Company.

Reviewed by Harry W. De Long.

The well-known magazine writer of short stories, Mary Rider Mechtold has given to filmdom an innovation in this Western story, and James Kirkwood used his fine Italian hand and artistic qualifications, assisted by the participating actors, in presenting a highly enjoyable and intensified visualization.

One of the most noticeable and creditable features pertaining, and an original one, perhaps the original Western picture, wherein there is not a shot fired. The cast contains four stars who enjoy, almost equal roles: Henry Walthall, “Douglas Williams”; Irene Hunt, his sweetheart in the East; Dorothy Gish has the title role, “Nell, The Mountain Rat”; Donald Crisp, “Steve,” Nell’s devoted admirer. The author evidently knows her characters and the locations in which she has banged them down to work out their destinies.

The elements of popularity obtain in this offering, which contains not only plenty of action but gripping heart interest, and there is nothing of the trite in the wholesome and beautiful California atmosphere, where it was produced. It will, or should, appeal to every audience. While there are many scenes amongst the rough-and-ready cowboys and miners, the delicacy with which they are handled eradicates any feeling of nauseousness, which attack the observer occasionally in pictures of a similar nature.

Dorothy Gish is called upon to essay a role that combines two opposite natures, and the clever little lady never wavers in her portrayal of either. Henry Walthall, in the difficult part of a dissolute young scion of a worthy family, who through drink is never himself, weak and selfish at all times, is at his best; which is saying something. Donald Crisp, as “Steve,” who is cast as a steady Westerner, in love with Nell, is the prototype of the part. His stoicism gives strength to the whole. Irene Hunt is not happy in her role, a thankless one, and failed to convince. The large supporting cast is fully adequate.

The story opens in the Eastern home of Douglas Williams (Walthall), and he is being upbraided by his mother for his dissolute ways. She informs him that his fiancee, in disgust, has decided not to marry him. He resolves to go west and redeem himself, which he does (goes west), but associates, on his arrival, with rough company and meets “Nell, The Mountain Rat,” who is queen of the dance hall at which he is a guest. Instead of reforming he indulges himself and through a scrimmage with an old miner both are thrown out. Douglas stakes the miner and is made a partner in a prospective gold mine. Returning to the saloon, in another brawl he is beaten to insensibility and taken to Nell’s cabin by Steve who is head-over-heels in love with Nell and proposes to her. She refuses him because she does not love him, but “likes him, just the same.” She has fallen in love with Douglas who, after many interesting scenes and adventures, including a visit from his mother and former sweetheart, who gives him up and returns East, marries Nell. The old miner strikes pay dirt which makes them all rich. The intense acting in the complications, at this period of the picture, is wonderful. Steve’s sacrifice of himself and his love in going for the minister, and being left to hold the horses in the finale, while the girl he loves becomes another’s, is sob fetching. The photography is first class in every respect.

—

Scene from The Mountain Rat (R. & M.)

—

Collection: Moving Picture World, May 1914