The Lion and the Mouse (1914)

March 20, 2026

—

Ethel Clayton | Gaston Bell | Barry O’Neil (Director |Story)

Rest of cast:

George Soule Spencer | Bartley McCullum | Robert Dunbar | Eleanor Barry | Lila Leslie | Richard Morris | Carlotta Doti | Ruth Bryan | Walter C. Prichard | Charles Klein (Play | Screenplay) | Fred Chaston (Cinematographer) | Siegmund Lubin (Producer)

—

see also

  • The Lion and the Mouse (1919)
  • The Lion and the Mouse (1928)

—

“The Lion and the Mouse”

Unprecedented hit in Lubin six-reel picturization of Charles Klein’s play — General Film Company’s special release.

Reviewed by Hanford C. Judson.

Motion picture making as an art most emphatically justifies itself in the new Lubin presentation of The Lion and the Mouse. There are stories that easily adapt themselves to screen portrayal, while others — and you will find that they are artificial in form even though they be, like Oedipus Tyranus, tremendously human in spirit — refuse to make first class pictures. The Lion and the Mouse is of the former. We have a clear memory of the play and it seems to us that on the stage the human bigness of the story was cramped even with all the help that Klein’s brilliant dialogue could give it, whereas on the screen untrammeled though voiceless, with the actual capitol at Washington shown and all the other sets and backgrounds far more real than any stage setting could make them seem, the story comes closer to us and the reality of it is more impressive. “This is no stage story,” it catches us saying; “it is a page of modern history.” Let us say that the reviewer was himself impressed and made a bit uncritical by admiration; yet probably no more critical audience could be found for it than the large but specially invited gathering of picture people who saw it at the American Theater recently, and one and all most enthusiastically indorsed it. The applause was very decided and hearty.

The picture is made greater than the play most by the greater emphasis that it gives to the love story. The stage version, with its dialogue, seemed to be a political situation with a love story to make it real; here, as the human heart really demands, the order is reversed. The political situation is just as clear as in the play; nothing has been lost and much gained by the fact that it is made to serve the love story; for, in turn, the love story made greater makes the political situation more poignant. Poignant it surely is until the happy ending which expectancy is made to hope for but kept uncertain of from the first. It is a wholesome, human, heart-satisfying picture and it is a terrible indictment. It is a spectator’s picture.

In it is exemplified the peculiar advantage that the screen has over the stage in the fluidity of the material it uses in building the story. Our fates don’t come to us out of the blue sky. On the stage, dialogue can subtly suggest the building up of fates; but the screen can show it. Then the play couldn’t emphasize the beginnings of the love story of Jeff Ryder and Shirley Rossmore; couldn’t show us their happiness together in the time before they knew that their sunshine wasn’t to remain unclouded. The picture does, and doing so keeps us, by the convincing reality of it, from suspecting that it was “dragged in” to lend human “punch” to the Money Trust story.

We already know that John Burkett Ryder, the money king, has had Judge Rossmore impeached; but the lovers whom we see on the steamer coming across the Atlantic don’t, and we alone know what’s waiting for them. We had seen the upright judge, played with fine humanity by Bartley McCullum and indeed the best thing in the whole picture, signing the paper that will stir the ire of the money king. This man is played by George Soule Spenser with a touch now and then that suggests Napoleon. It is not wholly satisfying but will not be unpopular. True and human and full of pathos are those scenes in which the judge’s wife, Eleanor Barry, whose weakness had left the way open for his trouble, now in tenderness tries to comfort him as he waits in a committee room of the capitol for the verdict and, later, cares for him in their little cottage. Admirably bright and satisfying are the love scenes on the ship, shown at this point, with Ethel Clayton as Shirley, the girl, and Gaston Bell as Jefferson Ryder, the young man. Hardly less pleasing is the homecoming of Shirley, her brave-hearted comforting of her parents and her break-down when they have gone up stairs and she is left alone with her father’s old friend Judge Scott, played by Richard Morris.

Much care has been shown in all the scenes that go with the development of the story. The obsequious flunkies at Ryder’s home and his solemnly impressive English secretary, by Walter C. Prichard, are valuable in the story and especially so is the care with which the great man is shown as guarded in his office from unimportant or bothersome visitors together with the itching eagerness of business men and schemers to get in to him. Then the social activities in the Ryder house are peacefully pictured. Mrs. Ryder (Carlotta Doti), is a good rich man’s wife, a sweet smiler upon her lord, quite careless that she is half neglected, who tries to make a comrade of her boy and is a good hostess. Cleverly brought out is the brisk fencing of Shirley and Ryder when the latter has read her book on the Money Trust and been impressed with the author’s knowledge of what he thought was his own secrets. Short notes pass between them and the heroine wins a point every time until the financier has to have his wife invite her to come so that he can talk with her.

Quite satisfying to the mind is the scene at the meeting between the astonished Jefferson and his father’s guest, “Miss Sarah Green,” author of a book that has caused a stir; but the final struggle of the girl to get evidence that will rehabilitate her father, while winning fresh laurels at certain points and quite adequate in its exposition of the action, has not, in itself, quite the emphatic emphasis that, as we recall it, the play’s dialogue gives the last scene. But there is not in the picture at any point the slightest feeling that the story has fallen down; it is good through all six reels. Among the lesser players, and all deserve notice, are Ruth Bryan, as Kate Roberts, and Lillie Leslie, the adventuress. The photography, except at one or two unimportant and short passages, is perfect.

—

Scene from The Lion and the Mouse (Lubin)

—

Collection: Moving Picture World, February 1914